Key Takeaways
- Collaborative divorce may involve multiple professionals, including financial experts, attorneys, child specialists, and mental health professionals.
- Mediation is more cost-effective as it entails hiring a single mediator to facilitate the process.
- The collaborative divorce process requires the separating couple and their attorney to sign a legally binding collaborative agreement.
- The mediation process’s success hinges on the couple’s willingness to communicate respectfully and accept compromise in most areas.
Going through any type of divorce is already challenging without adding the court process. So, if you dread the litigation process, collaborative divorce and mediation are the most ideal options available for you.
These approaches are regarded as alternative dispute resolution that assists couples in settling matters amicably outside the courtroom.
Although collaborative divorce and mediation enable you to stay out of court, they operate differently in their approaches, processes, and outcomes.
The next section will explore both options and explain the process involved. Afterward, we will summarize their pros and cons, assisting you to make an informed decision before signing your divorce agreement.
What Is Collaborative Divorce?
Collaborative divorce is a legal alternative dispute resolution process in which each party employs an attorney with experience in collaborative law. The legal professional works with the couple to help them reach an agreement that settles most disputes. The process entails the parties discussing their concerns and working towards finding a fair solution.
The downside of collaborative divorce is that the attorneys must fully withdraw from the case if the process is unsuccessful. You cannot use the same lawyer in litigation.
A notable benefit of collaborative divorce is that other professionals can get involved in the process. They assist by facilitating discussions in areas such as child support and financial arrangements.
Divorce mediation is the process of resolving issues between separating couples with a third party called a mediator.
The mediator should be neutral to both sides, and their role is to assist both parties in reaching a settlement agreement. The mediator can be an individual trained in mediation or an attorney.
Unlike collaborative divorce attorneys who can give advice or take the side of the party that hired them, a divorce mediator doesn't take sides or give advice. They only act as facilitators to help the couple communicate better, identify the issues, and guide them toward reaching an agreement.
Collaborative Law In Divorce
Collaborative law entails divorcing parties agreeing to work together to reach an agreement that fairly serves their interests as they end the marriage. The divorcing couple and their lawyers sign a collaborative divorce agreement stating that they agree to:
- Be respectful to each other
- Be sincere with each other and the entire process
- Disclose the relevant information vital to the divorcing process
- Hire neutral professionals
- Maintain confidentiality throughout the process
In addition to the above, the parties agree to avoid going to court to settle the dispute. Instead, they can propose stopping the process at any point if they are dissatisfied with the progress.
Collaborative Divorce Process
The following are the steps to take for the divorce collaborative process to be fair, effective, and legally binding:
- Each spouse chooses and hires an attorney: The lawyer chosen to perform this task must be familiar with collaborative divorce practice and not focused on court processes.
- The couple and attorneys sign a collaborative agreement: This agreement contains the expectations of the process and limits the attorneys' involvement in it.
- Each spouse meets with their lawyer: Each party shares their position and desired outcome with their attorney. Discuss your limits and decide on crucial issues before entering the negotiation room.
- Start the collaborative meetings: Meet with your spouse and their attorney and start by resolving the pressing issues. Where needed, invite a child expert, financial advisor, or accountant to assist with ironing out issues.
- File the collaborative divorce agreement in court: The filing process is easier because you have already decided on everything. The settlement agreement you present to the court should include the terms and conditions for child support, co-parenting, and asset division.
The collaborative divorce cost is manageable if the process does not have complications that require additional meetings and multiple experts invited.
Using mediation in the divorce process only works if the separating couple is willing to communicate and work together, there is little to no history of domestic violence or emotional abuse, and one spouse has not filed a fault divorce.
Once you have identified a neutral mediator, you will go through the following process:
- Before mediation: The mediator will request information about your marriage, family, and pending divorce issues. You may also be required to sign an agreement stating you agree to enter the mediation process and keep the discussions confidential.
- During mediation: The mediator may request a private meeting with each spouse before the sessions take off. Each spouse will have time to air their views as the mediator guides the discussions. The duration depends on the number of issues and how quickly you resolve the matter with your spouse.
- Finalizing the agreement: After you negotiate and amicably agree on all the issues, the mediator will draft an agreement for you to sign. They can also help you file the paperwork in court if that's part of the service they provide.
Once the court approves your settlement agreement, it will be legally enforceable and part of the final divorce decree.
Pros And Cons Of Collaborative And Mediation Divorce
At this point in the discussion, you may have already picked out the benefits and drawbacks of both processes. The option you pick must have benefits that meet your pressing needs. You must also be willing to work with the drawbacks.
Now, let’s look at the pros and cons of collaborative and mediation divorce.
Pros and cons of collaborative divorce
If we look at collaborative divorce, there are several upsides and downsides. They are summarized in the following table.
| Pros of collaborative divorce
|
Cons of collaborative divorce
|
| Both parties control outcomes and can customize for their needs.
|
It can be expensive due to hiring lawyers and experts.
|
| Process is confidential
|
It may take longer due to more people involved.
|
| Less emotional strain
|
Does not work well if one party is uncooperative
|
On the other hand, mediation divorce also has its advantages and disadvantages:
| Pros of mediation divorce
|
Cons of mediation divorce
|
| Less expensive due to hiring only one mediator
|
One party may feel less empowered compared to a collaborative
|
| The streamlined process enables a quick process and outcomes
|
Doesn’t work well if there’s a communication breakdown
|
| Minimizes emotional stress
|
There can be an unwillingness to negotiate
|
Divorce requires multiple documents to ensure both parties do their part. Make sure you’re prepared for whatever your situation may require with the right process and documents.
Start a Divorce Agreement now
Helpful Resources:
CA Civ Pro Code § 1775